Blog

November 11, 2026 DRB Minutes

SOUTH HERO DEVELOPMENT REVIEW BOARD MINUTES

November 11, 2026

 

Members Present: Doug Patterson (Chair); Jim Brightwell (Vice-Chair); Liza Kilcoyne; Nate Hayward; Sherry Dupont.

Members Absent: Tim Mullen.  Recused from Hearing: Gareth Hunt

 

Others Present (In Person): Martha Taylor-Varney, Zoning Administrator (ZA); Mitchel Richardson (Applicant); Brady Baker; Penelope Cunningham; Michael Frett (The Islander); Deb Lang; Laura Heaberlin; Ted Kriss; Peg Kirk; Matthew Brooks; Janine Banks; Bob Desrosiers; Deborah Johnson; Georgine Natelli; Meg Lewellen; Susan Ryan; Jessica Audette; Richard Monterosso; Dotty Donovan; K.P. Donovan; Leah Hills; Andrew Hills; Carol Sepkoski; Jonathan Kirkpatrick; Bill & Jane Kirkpatrick; Tina Bissonette; Peter St. Clair; Teresa Palatino; Fred Palatino; Jim Ferro; Michael Inners; Nathan Mauser; Janet Barquist; Julie Kirkpatrick; Marie Tofo.

 

Others Present (Via Zoom): Joe Bissonnette; dbanks; Sam Hilliker; Timothy Neville; Adam; Ellen Long-Mid; Adison Kanouse; Bridget Kerr; Peter Mazurak (Apex Engineering); Zoom User; Scott Dingerson; Britni Myers; Alisha Utter; Dave Service; Patricia Angus.

 

7:01 PM — Chair D. Patterson called the meeting to order and read the agenda.

 

Changes to the Agenda

There were none.

 

Public Input

There was no public input regarding non-agenda items.

 

Continued Conditional Use Review for a Proposed Compost Facility at 138 Ferry Rd. (#27-26-FR138 – Mitchel Richardson)

D. Patterson introduced the Board and opened the continued hearing. Applicant Mitchel Richardson was present.

Housekeeping / Correspondence Entered into the Record:

ZA Martha Taylor-Varney read five items of correspondence received since the October 28, 2026 hearing:

  1. A letter from Ben Gauthier of the Agency of Natural Resources (ANR) Solid Waste Division regarding ANR jurisdiction.
  2. Written responses from Apex Engineering to the Board’s questions from the October 28, 2026 hearing.
  3. A map of the Grand Isle Consolidated Water District (GICWD) Source Protection Area, received November 11, 2026.
  4. Four letters of opposition from Fred Palatino, Lynn & James Farrell, Doug & Bridget Kerr, and Joseph Bissonette.
  5. A petition received just prior to the meeting.

 L. Kilcoyne moved to enter the five correspondence items into the record; J. Brightwell second. All in favor.

 

Board Questions & Applicant Testimony:

  • Facility Dimensions & Existing Pads: The Board reviewed the response letter from Apex Engineering (noted as unsigned) and questioned the first item regarding a 66′ x 180′ manure stacking pad. Mitchel clarified that the 66′ x 180′ structure is the existing barn (“bedded pack”), which has been in place for approximately 15 years (since 2008). The concrete stacking/compost pad adjacent to the barn measures 35′ x 180′ and was installed approximately two years ago under Agency of Agriculture guidelines.
  • Volumes & Capacity: Mitchel explained that his current volume from the bedded pack (an 80/20 mix of carbon bedding such as wood chips, straw, or sawdust, and manure) is 3,520 cubic yards. The site plan accounts for a total capacity of 4,940 cubic yards, leaving room for 1,420 cubic yards of imported material. Under Agency of Agriculture regulations, he can import up to 2,000 cubic yards per year of food scraps and residuals without needing an ANR permit, provided no animal carcasses or slaughterhouse waste are included. Including slaughterhouse waste (specifically blood and trimmings for nitrogen) triggers ANR jurisdiction and requires DRB Conditional Use approval.
  • Composting Process & Site Layout: At the Board’s request, Mitchel walked through the step-by-step operations on the site plan:
    1. Stage 1 (Bedded Pack / Barn): Manure and carbon bedding accumulate in the barn. Cleanouts occur once or twice a year.
    2. Stage 2 (Aerated Static Pile / Manure Stack Pad): Material from the barn is moved to the adjacent 35′ x 180′ concrete pad, where incoming food scraps and slaughterhouse renderings are immediately mixed in and capped with carbon (80% carbon to 20% nitrogen/residuals) to control odors and vectors. Perforated 8-inch black poly pipes blow air through the piles, accelerating the heat-treatment process from 30 days down to 3 days. Batches are formed weekly (up to ~15–18 small batches at a time) and must reach and maintain 131°F for at least 3 days to kill pathogens, remaining undisturbed on this pad for 30 days.
    3. Stage 3 (Residuals Compost Pad): After the 30-day heat-treat phase, batches are moved via loader to the second light-gray pad area for final curing and windrow mixing for approximately 6 months until finished.
    4. Stage 4 (Vegetated Treatment Area): The green area on the plan is a sloped grass buffer designed to filter leachate and runoff from the pads, removing sediment before water enters the ground or surrounding areas.
  • Deliveries & Operations: 2,000 cubic yards equates to roughly 100–125 tandem dump truck loads per year, though deliveries may arrive in smaller loads (e.g., roll-offs or pails). Incoming material is capped with carbon the same day to prevent odor and pests. Mitchel noted he has employees to help operate the site and does not intend to run it solely himself.
  • Comparison Facilities & Jurisdictions: Mitchel noted he visited Green Mountain Compost (Williston, operated by Casella) and Hudak Farms (Swanton) to observe operations. He explained that Green Mountain Compost is a large commercial enterprise (handling ~10,000+ cubic yards/year) using similar aerated static pile technology, while Hudak Farms is a smaller agricultural operation. He noted that Vermont’s Act 148 requires food scraps to be diverted from landfills, and ANR is encouraging on-farm composting to keep organic matter out of landfills like Casella’s.
  • Land & Nutrient Management: Mitchel stated the 3-lot subdivision consists of Lot 2 (8.6 acres, where the barn and compost facility sit), Lot 3 (8.94 acres, rotational grazing), and Lot 1 (24.72 acres in South Hero, plus ~110 contiguous acres in Grand Isle, used for grazing and cropping). He owns roughly 100 acres on the home farm and leases/farms another 450 acres off-site (including ~200 acres at Eagle Camp). He initiated the project under a voluntary Nutrient Management Plan because commercial nitrogen fertilizer has become prohibitively expensive. Under Agency of Agriculture rules, he must use at least 51% of the finished compost on land he farms, and may sell up to 49% off-farm. He clarified he has no plans to expand into a commercial operation exceeding the 49% limit, and confirmed he is no longer operating an automotive repair business on the property.

 

Site Visits:

The Board discussed conducting site visits to Mitchel’s farm and Green Mountain Compost (and potentially Hudak Farms) to observe operations firsthand before the ground freezes.

 J. Brightwell moved to schedule a DRB site visit on Friday, November 20, 2026, starting at 9:00 AM at Crimson Clover Family Farm (138 Ferry Rd.), proceeding afterward to Green Mountain Compost in Williston (and potentially Hudak Farms, time permitting); N. Hayward second. All in favor.

(Note: Mitchel agreed to stake out the proposed new pad prior to the visit. Board members noted that no testimony will be taken during the site visit, though members of the public are welcome to attend and observe.)

 

Zoom Chat Questions & Jurisdictional Clarification:

ZA M. Taylor-Varney read questions submitted via Zoom chat:

  • Adison Kanouse (listed in Zoom chat as Zach Canoose) stated he emailed a letter of opposition at 9:42 AM; Martha noted she did not receive it and asked him to resend it.
  • Zoom participants—including Timothy Neville, Sam Hilliker, Bridget Kerr, and Patricia Angus—asked about camera visibility (adjusted by the Board), definitions of residuals, winter composting times (ANR confirmed no change in winter), regulatory oversight (ANR), and whether the hearing must be re-warned. Martha noted she and Chair Patterson are meeting with the Town Attorney tomorrow (November 12) to confirm whether the application was properly warned under South Hero’s regulations and to clarify whether the use qualifies as an allowed conditional use.
  • Site Plan Deficiencies: Martha and the Board informed Mitchel and his engineer (Peter Mazurak, attending via Zoom) that the current drawing is a sketch/site layout rather than a complete site plan. To proceed to Site Plan Review, the applicant must submit a revised plan meeting all requirements of Table 3.2 of the South Hero Development Regulations (including a location map, scale, north arrow, date, 2-foot contours, property/zoning boundaries, structures, access points, culverts, landscaping, construction sequence, and traffic generation). Peter confirmed via chat that he would prepare a compliant plan.

 

Questions and Comments from the Public:

  • Bob Desrosiers: Stated all of his questions had already been asked and answered by the Board and applicant.
  • Deb Lang (Maynard Court, Grand Isle): Requested Interested Party status and notification of future meetings, noting her home is within line of sight of the facility. Expressed strong concerns about odors from decomposing animal products, vectors (flies, mice, rats), and wildlife (foxes/vermin) being attracted to the site, noting that the farm’s cows frequently escape their fencing onto Route 314.
  • Peter St. Clair (595 West Shore Rd., abutting property): Stated that while he supports farming, bringing in off-site slaughterhouse waste exceeds the scale of normal on-farm composting and moves the operation into light industrial/commercial territory. Raised concerns about nutrient runoff (phosphorus and nitrogen) reaching Lake Champlain during heavy rain or frozen ground conditions, foul odors from anaerobic piles, and respiratory health risks from bioaerosols (especially for residents with COPD or lung conditions). Martha requested a copy of his written statement be entered into the record.
  • Michael Inners (Grand Isle Consolidated Water District Board of Commissioners): Requested Interested Party status on behalf of GICWD, noting the district maintains a municipal water intake in Lake Champlain nearby and the subject property drains directly into the GICWD Source Protection Area. Submitted a supporting letter to accompany the map entered earlier.
  • Georgine Natelli (139 Ferry Rd.): Pointed out an inconsistency in testimony: while the applicant stated the compost is needed to replace nitrogen fertilizer on the 138 Ferry Rd. farm, he also stated the bulk of the compost will be used off-site on leased land (such as Eagle Camp). Argued the facility will provide no benefit to South Hero while negatively impacting neighbors.
  • Fred Palatino (5 West Shore Rd., abutting property): Expressed concern about runoff into Lake Champlain, noting a culvert at the northwest corner of the property drains directly into the lake. Questioned how the vegetated grass buffer will filter runoff during winter and early spring storms when the ground is frozen.
  • Richard Monterosso (414 West Shore Rd.): Stated he was in support of farming, but was concerned about the animal products. Is this an accessory on-farm use or commercial?  Concerned about odor and runoff.
  • Nathan Mauser: Commented on a French drain along the town boundary that takes runoff directly from this property to Lake Champlain. Later asked Mitchel whether he plans to sell any of the finished compost, noting that up to 49% could legally be sold; Mitchel responded that he will not be selling it.
  • Tina Bissonette: Questioned how a site visit in November would accurately reflect conditions in August regarding odors, bioaerosols, and complaints associated with open composting sites (such as birds dropping materials from the site).
  • Brady Baker: Expressed concern about odors from dead animals, describing the smell as horrendous. Raised concerns about whether spreading the compost around the community could result in well contamination and questioned whether this is a commercial or agricultural proposal.
  • Laura Heaberlin: Expressed concern about odors. Noted that the Grand Isle Consolidated Water District Source Protection Area is located just outside her home, and stated that local zoning is their only protection against contamination.
  • Matthew Brooks: Asked how efficient compost is compared to nitrogen fertilizers; Mitchel responded that compost is more efficient and longer lasting.
  • Ted Kriss: Requested Interested Party status. Asked whether the Board could look online at examples of composting facilities outside of Vermont to get assessments from local contacts near those sites. Expressed concerns regarding odor, lake water quality, and cows getting loose onto yards and neighboring properties.

 

Recess / Continuation of Hearing:

L. Kilcoyne moved to continue the hearing to Wednesday, January 27, 2027, at 7:00 PM at the South Hero Town Office; N. Hayward second. All in favor.

 

Review of Minutes from October 28, 2026

J. Brightwell moved to approve the minutes from October 28, 2026; L. Kilcoyne second. All in favor.

 

Administrator’s Report

  • Upcoming Meeting Schedule:
    • November 25, 2026: No meeting.
    • December 9, 2026: Final Plan Review for a major subdivision for Allenholm.
    • December 23, 2026: No meeting.
    • January 13, 2027: Final Plan Review for a major subdivision for Ross Brown, and Sketch Plan Review for a major subdivision for Hayward.
    • January 27, 2027: Continuation of the Mitchel Richardson compost facility hearing.
  • ZA Availability: ZA Martha Taylor-Varney will be out of the office from December 10 through December 21, 2026, but will be working remotely during that time.
  • Board Membership Update: Britni Myers was introduced to the Board. She will be replacing her husband, Justin Myers, as an alternate member of the Development Review Board. The Selectboard will formally appoint her prior to the next meeting, and she will attend the December 9, 2026 meeting as a member.

 

Adjournment

S. Dupont moved to adjourn at 9:00 PM; N. Hayward second. All in favor; the meeting was adjourned.

 

Respectfully submitted,

 

Martha Taylor-Varney, ZA

 

Signed: ________________________________________ Date: _____________________

 

These minutes are unofficial until approved at the next regularly scheduled meeting. All motions were unanimous unless otherwise indicated.

https://us06web.zoom.us/rec/share/jIEX3SNYAGxTfDMb6DRvYNKeAdI2YwH6KkpiEeh7f9vZE64rKJq_3uoArM606TKC.JLP0mZ82dS7F9Rb1

Passcode: F1Bt#QB9